What a percentile means
Imagine a player at the 90th percentile. His estimate is at or above roughly 90% of the values in the comparison group. That does not mean he has a 90% chance of being a good player.
We compare forwards with forwards and defencemen with defencemen, using the recent three-season record of current NHL skaters with at least 60 covered games. Historical player pages use that same comparison group rather than ranking a player against everyone from his own era.
The overall rating compares WAR per 82 games. The component ratings compare accumulated contribution in the covered games. One describes the pace of overall value; the others show where the recorded contribution came from.
How the overall labels work
The overall WAR-per-82 rating uses these percentile bands:
| Label | Percentile |
|---|---|
| Elite | 92nd and above |
| Strong | 75th to below 92nd |
| Average | 25th to below 75th |
| Weak | 8th to below 25th |
| Poor | Below 8th |
These are broad descriptions of position within the group. A player near the bottom of an NHL comparison is not necessarily below replacement level: replacement is a different baseline.
Read across a boundary
Consider two hypothetical players at the 74.9th and 75.1st percentiles. One receives Average and the other Strong. They sit almost beside each other in the ranking, despite the different words.
The cutoff makes the display readable. It doesn't establish a meaningful difference in ability. When making a hockey decision, read the actual contribution, workload, role and price alongside the label. Our uncertainty explainer discusses those close calls.
What the component labels add
The five component cards show a player's mix of process, finishing, power-play contribution, penalty killing and penalties.
A component is labelled a strength at the 80th percentile or above, or a weakness below the 20th, provided its contribution is at least 0.35 wins away from zero. Smaller contributions receive a typical label even if their percentile is high or low. That floor keeps small totals from dominating the description; it is not a measured error bar.
Special teams also require enough deployment before we make the comparison. Rarely used means the player had little opportunity in that role, not that he was an average performer there.
The profile is most useful when it explains the shape of a player's contribution. Two similar overall ratings can hide very different strengths, workloads and jobs.
Why an article may give a different standing
Articles compare regular forwards or defencemen with at least 500 five-on-five minutes in a season, or 1,500 across three seasons. They give standings in steps of 5%, such as top 10% or bottom 25%.
That group includes players who may no longer be in the league; player-page ratings use qualified current players. The period and treatment of ties can also differ. A different standing can therefore describe the same performance against a different comparison group.