Add the strengths and weaknesses
Imagine a skater with these hypothetical season contributions:
| Component | Wins above average |
|---|---|
| Five-on-five process | +0.6 |
| Finishing | +0.3 |
| Power play | +0.2 |
| Penalty kill | −0.1 |
| Penalties drawn and taken | +0.1 |
| Total | +1.1 |
The positive contributions outweigh the negative one. The result is 1.1 wins above average, with five-on-five play supplying the largest part.
These are estimates on a common win scale, not a count of games the player personally won. Each component converts its goal contribution using the relevant scoring environment.
Average is not replacement
An average NHL regular can still be much more useful than the depth player available to take his minutes. That is why WAA and wins above replacement answer different questions.
Suppose the replacement baseline for the example’s workload is 0.5 wins below average. The gap from replacement to this player is:
1.1 − (−0.5) = 1.6 WAR.
The replacement adjustment is made once for the whole player. We do not add it separately to process, finishing or every other component.
Likewise, slightly negative WAA does not automatically mean a player is below replacement. It means his estimated contribution fell below the average comparison point.
The components explain the role
Two players can reach the same total in different ways. One might drive the five-on-five chance battle; another might offset weaker five-on-five play with finishing and power-play work.
That matters when asking what a team needs. The total summarises contribution, while the components help explain how the player supplies it.
Missing evidence is different from a measured zero. If a component is unavailable, it does not establish average performance in that part of the game. Read the available coverage alongside the total.
On our player pages and in articles, WAR is the overall measure. WAA explains the average-relative contributions that go into it.