The Kings are better than this. The Predators aren't this good.
Our preseason roster ranking has mostly held through 20 games. The biggest risers are riding their goalies. The biggest fallers aren't scoring on the chances they create.
Before the season we did something simple with every roster: we added up what its opening-night skaters were worth last season, in wins above replacement. It ignored coaches. It ignored goalies. It was a sketch of how much proven talent each team was dressing, and nothing more.
About 20 games in, the sketch looks a lot like the standings. Through Saturday, seven of the ten best records in the league belonged to teams with a top-ten roster. The eight deepest rosters have taken 69% of the points available to them. The eight thinnest have taken 46%.
The other three teams in that top ten are Montreal, Nashville and Boston, and at the bottom of the standings sit two rosters that had no business being there, Pittsburgh and Los Angeles. Those are the season's real surprises. The three risers have something in common, and it's the part of the roster we left out. The two fallers mostly have a different problem.
The gap between chances and goals is where the surprises live
Add up the quality of every shot a team has taken and allowed and you get the goal difference its play has earned, its expected goals. Then look at the goal difference it actually has. Twenty games is short enough that the two can sit a long way apart, and for the surprise teams they do, in both directions.
By chances, Los Angeles has been the ninth-best team in the league. By chances, Nashville has been the 22nd. The standings have them 30th and tied for eighth.
Split those gaps between the two nets and a pattern shows. Boston, Nashville, Montreal and the Islanders each have a goalie near the top of this chart.
Los Angeles has out-chanced its opponents and sits 30th
The Kings are 5-11-2. They've also out-chanced their opponents by about seven goals, which is what good teams do. Nearly all of that edge has come away from five-on-five, where they've been even. Artemi Panarin has 19 points in 17 games.
The goals have gone missing at both ends. Kings shooters have scored about nine fewer than their chances were worth, and only three teams have fallen further short. Darcy Kuemper has the second-largest deficit of any goalie in the league, with an .873 save percentage in 11 starts. Anton Forsberg has been fine in the other seven.
We ranked this roster 19th, so nobody should mistake it for a contender. But a middling roster generating a top-ten share of the chances is not a 30th-place team, and the way it's playing isn't the part that needs fixing.
Pittsburgh has been ordinary, with leaks at both ends
The Penguins are the biggest disappointment on our list: the eighth-best roster, and a 7-11-2 record that ranks 28th.
Part of that is on the skaters. At five-on-five they've had 52% of the expected goals, ninth in the league, but across all situations their chances for and against are dead even. That's a mid-table team, not a top-eight one.
The rest is spread across both nets. Pittsburgh's shooters are about five goals short of what their chances were worth. Arturs Silovs and Sergei Murashov have a combined .882 save percentage and are about three goals short between them. At five-on-five the Penguins have carried the play and been outscored 49–40 anyway. No single thing has turned ordinary into 28th, which also means there's no single thing to fix.
Buffalo and Columbus share the shooting half of that. Buffalo, 11th on our list, is 8-8-4 with shooters about eight goals short of their chances. Columbus, 18th and 7-11-0, is about nine short, with the league's lowest shooting percentage at 8.8%.
Nashville's record is Juuse Saros
The Predators are 11-4-5 with our 23rd-ranked roster. They aren't out-playing anyone. They've had 48% of the five-on-five expected goals, 23rd in the league, and they've been out-chanced overall.
Juuse Saros has allowed 34 goals on shots worth 45. He was about three goals better than expected across all of last season; he's been 11 better in 14 starts, with a .921 save percentage. Nashville has also collected five points from overtime and shootout losses.
Saros is a good goalie. He isn't this good, nobody is for long, and the team in front of him is playing like the roster we ranked 23rd.
Montreal found a goalie in October
The Canadiens were 14th on our list, so 12-4-4 is a smaller surprise, and it comes with an asterisk in their favour: Ivan Demidov, who went down with a lower-body injury in the first week, has played two games, and Nick Suzuki has missed six.
They've broken even on chances at five-on-five and outscored opponents 47–33 there. The difference is Jacob Fowler, called up on October 7 after Sam Montembeault left practice with an apparent injury. He has a .926 save percentage in 12 starts and has saved more goals above expected than all but one goalie in the league. In Montreal's other eight games, Jakub Dobes is at .852.
So the Canadiens are a decent team missing a top forward and getting elite goaltending from a 21-year-old in 12 of their 20 games. One of those things is likelier to last than the other.
Boston is the one we got wrong
The Bruins were 28th on our list. They're 13-6-1.
Some of this is the same story. Boston's .911 save percentage is third in the league and it's shooting 13%, fifth. Leave out empty-netters and its chances have earned a goal difference of about plus-one. It's plus-16.
But two things separate Boston from Nashville. The first is that the skaters have been better than their record said they were. A group that was below average at five-on-five last season has 53% of the expected goals there, fifth in the league. David Pastrnak has 26 points in 20 games, and James Hagens, who had played two NHL games before this season, has 12 in 17.
The second is that the goaltending isn't a surprise. Jeremy Swayman saved about 11 goals more than expected last season, fourth-best in the league. Our list just didn't count him. The same goes for the Islanders, 26th on our list and 9-6-4 behind Ilya Sorokin, who was second.
That's the lesson of the first 20 games. A skater ranking gets you most of the standings. The misses on the high side are in the crease, and they come in two kinds: goalies we should have counted, in Boston and on Long Island, and goalies running hot, in Nashville and Montreal. The misses on the low side are mostly teams scoring less than their chances were worth, plus one cold goalie in Los Angeles. Saros and Fowler have to keep this up for their teams to stay where they are. The Kings only need a few more to go in, and a few more to stay out.
Go deeper
Players and teams