Panarin creates. Dorofeyev defends. Both finish.
Same $11.0 million cap hit, different strengths. Dorofeyev can't replace Panarin's playmaking, but his defence deserves more credit.
The Rangers bought Pavel Dorofeyev for his goals, but his best five-on-five work comes on defence. That makes him a different kind of player from Artemi Panarin, the star he follows.
Why it matters: New York traded Panarin to Los Angeles in February, then gave Dorofeyev seven years at $11.0 million a season, the same cap hit Panarin now carries with the Kings. GM Chris Drury said Dorofeyev's production, "specifically in goals, is something we were in need of" (NHL.com). Fans hunting for Panarin's playmaking will be watching the wrong end.
The evidence from the last three seasons (Panarin's last one split between New York and LA):
- He's a defensive ace. Dorofeyev was in the top 5% of regular forwards at preventing chances at five-on-five, and in the top quarter in each of the three seasons.
- He isn't a play-driver. His chance creation was about average; Panarin's was in the top 5%.
- Both can shoot. Dorofeyev scored 85 goals on chances worth 67.4. Both players' finishing was in the top 5%.
Yes, but: The Athletic's player tiers say he's "not a true play-driver or a defensive ace" (The Athletic). The play-driver half holds. The defensive half doesn't, even after accounting for his teammates and opponents. The same piece's anonymous analyst expects "a regression now that he's away from the Vegas system," and that has a point: our adjustment can't capture Vegas's structure. Last season was his weakest of the three for creating and preventing five-on-five chances combined, while 20 of his 37 goals came on the power play.
The bottom line: Panarin was the better player. But Dorofeyev's overall contribution still put him in the top 15% of regular forwards. The Rangers bought a shooter who defends; judge him at both ends.
Go deeper
Players and teams