Brady Tkachuk was dangerous long before Florida
Three Ottawa seasons reveal a player whose ability to create danger ran far ahead of his finishing.
Brady Tkachuk brings two hat tricks in his last three games into his return to Ottawa. The Senators don't need the goals to know how dangerous he is. They spent years watching him cause trouble when the puck wouldn't go in.
He played eight seasons in Ottawa and was named captain at 22, wearing the C for the last five before Florida acquired him on June 21. On October 21, he walks into Canadian Tire Centre through the visitors' door. The city, he said Tuesday, “made me who I am.”
From 2023–24 through 2025–26, his five-on-five process ranked in the top 5% of regular forwards, and it held up in every one of those seasons. Most of it came at the offensive end. He made Ottawa more dangerous, and did a little to keep chances away from its own net.
His shooting is the other half of the story. His finishing, across all strengths, was bottom 5% over the same stretch, and it got worse each season. The chances kept coming. Too few of his own shots went in.
On chance impact, the chart puts him in a tight pack with Connor McDavid, Brandon Hagel and Zach Hyman, with Nathan MacKinnon out on his own. The whole game separates them. MacKinnon and McDavid contributed far more overall. By WAR per 82, Tkachuk ranked in the top 10%, right beside Hagel and Hyman. Florida traded for a first-line forward with one obvious flaw, not a project.
Then, for two nights, the flaw vanished. Across all strengths in the hat tricks on October 13 and 15, he scored six times on attempts worth about 1.2 expected goals. That's his Ottawa problem turned inside out. Only two of the goals came at five-on-five; the rest came on the power play, with an extra attacker and in three-on-three overtime.
The five-on-five picture in those two games is busier rather than cleaner. His own attempt rate more than doubled from his first six games. So did the danger at both ends: Florida created more with him on the ice, and gave up more still.
In Columbus, he scored three straight second-period goals, two on the power play. His brother Matthew set up all three and finished the night with five assists. Matthew credited quicker puck movement and net presence. Panthers coach Paul Maurice saw chemistry rooted in the brothers' childhood hockey.
The line arrived a game before the goals. Matthew and Sam Bennett were already Brady's main five-on-five linemates in Buffalo on October 12, a night he didn't score, and they stayed with him through both hat tricks.
Against Vancouver, Florida was down 2–0 in the third period. Brady scored all three goals in the 3–2 overtime win, one-timing the equalizer with 13 seconds left in regulation. Maurice praised his precise long-range shooting; Seth Jones called him “a true gamer.”
With Aleksander Barkov out with a lower-body injury and Brad Marchand sidelined by another, Florida needs those goals now. It didn't need them to justify the trade; it was getting one of the league's best chance drivers either way. Against Seattle on Saturday, Brady put seven shots on goal and didn't score. Whether the finishing lasts is the part nobody knows yet.
For three seasons, Ottawa got the chances without enough of the goals. On Wednesday, the Senators find out whether they now have to defend both.
Go deeper
Players and teams