Skip to content

Simon Edvinsson's numbers say Kevin Bahl, not Victor Hedman

An NHL executive says his breakout has already happened. We have him below replacement level in both of his full seasons.

2 min read

Simon Edvinsson reportedly prefers a trade out of Detroit, but his two full seasons, 2024–25 and 2025–26, show a big defenceman whose good shot can't cover what his defence and penalties cost.

Why it matters: The unsigned RFA has to sign by Dec. 1, with Detroit or in a sign-and-trade, to play this season, and a long-term deal was reportedly expected to cost more than $10 million a season. That's top-pair money, whoever pays it.

  • Defence is the weak spot. Even after accounting for partners and opponents, his chance prevention ranks in the bottom 15% of regular defencemen.
  • So are the penalties. He took more per game than all but eight regular defencemen. He draws his share, but the net costs Detroit about as much as his defence.
  • The shot is the bright spot, but a small one. He scores more than his chances are worth, with finishing in the top 25%, and creates chances at about an average rate.
  • His closest match is Kevin Bahl. Bahl, another 6-foot-6 left shot, has the profile nearest his: costly in chances allowed and penalties, with an almost identical WAR rate.
Wins per 82 games, 2024–25 and 2025–26: Edvinsson's chance prevention and penalties cost far more than his finishing added, leaving him below replacement level.

Yes, but: An executive on The Athletic's player-tiers panel said, "The breakout has already happened," and The Hockey Writers called him "a top-tier shutdown blueliner" on a pair with Moritz Seider.

Our answer: split the credit between them and Seider's chance prevention ranks in the top 5%, Edvinsson's in the bottom 15%. Daily Faceoff, citing adjusted plus-minus, wrote that his help on Detroit's back end "hasn't shown up in the numbers yet." Regular partners are hard to pull apart, but nobody else took his penalties.

How he plays: "He's a freak athletically, can skate and his skill game has come a long, long way," a coach told The Athletic's panel.

The bottom line: Before the 2021 draft, Frölunda's GM compared him to Victor Hedman, whose WAR rate at the same ages ranked in the top 25% of regular defencemen of his day. Edvinsson's record so far looks like Bahl's. Top-pair money for him buys the tools, not the results.

Go deeper

Keep reading