Skip to content

Pettersson fell from star to good, never to bad

In his worst seasons, he was still a top-quarter forward. He just wasn't an $11.6 million one.

2 min read

Elias Pettersson has 15 points in 14 games, and The Athletic's Harman Dayal calls him "halfway back." The slump he's climbing out of cost Vancouver a star, not a useful player.

Why it matters: The Canucks are last in the NHL at 3-10-1. Pettersson has six seasons left at $11.6 million with a reported no-movement clause, and Dayal notes he's on Chris Johnston's latest trade board. Is that money buying a star or a good player?

  • The fall was real. In 2022–23, he was among the five best forwards in the league by WAR per 82 games. By 2024–25 and 2025–26, it was down about three quarters.
  • It stopped at good. Both years, he was still better than about 75% of regular forwards.
  • The contract is what he hasn't lived up to. Those were the first two years of his extension, and his play was worth $7.1 million and $7.4 million per 82 games in WAR $, well short of the $11.6 million cap hit. He said as much in March: "I haven't lived up to expectations of contract."
  • His scoring hasn't come back at five-on-five. All four of his goals this season came on the power play. At five-on-five, Vancouver was outchanced with him on the ice over his first 12 games, though by less than without him.
Each dot is a regular forward's WAR $ per 82 games. Pettersson ranked 4th of 380 in 2022–23. In the first two seasons of his extension he was in the top quarter, below his $11.6 million cap hit.

Yes, but: The good that's left is narrow. Over those two seasons, drawing more penalties than he took produced 62% of his WAR, while his five-on-five chance creation and finishing slipped below average. Dayal's tracking points the same way: his rush offence, skating and five-on-five shot creation are "nearly identical to last year and still far below his peak."

The bottom line: Pettersson never became a bust. He became a good player on a star's contract, and a hot start without a five-on-five goal isn't proof he's a star again.

Go deeper

Keep reading