Evan Bouchard's bad-defender label is four seasons out of date
Last season he held down opponents' chances better than any of the three Norris finalists.
Evan Bouchard has opened the season with eight points in two games. The offence is impossible to miss. His defence deserves a second look too.
Why it matters: Bouchard promised at camp to put defence first. But his five-on-five chance prevention hasn't been below average since 2021–22. The question for coach Mike Babcock is how much needs fixing.
The evidence:
- Better than about 70% of regular defencemen. That's his five-on-five chance prevention per minute from 2023–24 to 2025–26. Single-season comparisons below use that season's regulars.
- Ahead of the Norris field last season. He was in the top quarter, ahead of Zach Werenski, Cale Makar and Rasmus Dahlin. Over three seasons, Makar was better.
- The label once fit. In 2021–22 he was in the bottom 30%.
- The offence dwarfs it. Over three seasons, his five-on-five attack was worth about four times as many wins as his defence. Next to that, good defence looks like a weakness.
Yes, but: The Athletic's September player-tiers panel put his flaws mainly in his play without the puck. Our measure adjusts for playing with McDavid and Draisaitl, but it also credits chances prevented by keeping the puck, which is defence too. It can't isolate his play without it.
How he plays: “It's the subtle little plays that he makes that are so good,” Connor McDavid told NHL.com.
The bottom line: Bouchard isn't a bad defender. He's an elite attacker with good defence and memorable mistakes. Babcock should trim the blunders, not rebuild the player.
Go deeper
Players and teams