Skip to content

Gauthier's shot didn't change. Anaheim's power play did.

Ten of his 15 goals have come with the man advantage, on a unit that just went 16 for 27. At five-on-five he's scoring about what his chances are worth.

2 min read

Cutter Gauthier scored his third hat trick in five games Sunday, and the run is less a shooter arriving than a power play finally built around one who already had.

Why it matters: Thirteen goals in six games has Daily Faceoff's Michael Bondy asking whether he's a 70-goal scorer, two months after Anaheim signed him for six years and $81 million. How much of this he keeps depends on which part is his.

  • Five-on-five looks like last year. He's taking 3.5 unblocked shots a game there, against 3.9 last season, from the same distance.
  • The power play is now his. He's on the ice for 80% of Anaheim's power-play time, up from 53% last season, and his shots there have nearly doubled.
  • The looks aren't better. More are going in. Over the last two seasons he scored on about one power-play shot in 10. This season it's one in four.
  • It isn't only him. His teammates have half of those 16 power-play goals in the six games. In the 12 games before, Anaheim went 9 for 38.
Five-on-five
Cutter Gauthier at five-on-five, 2026–27 through Nov. 8: 4 goals on chances worth 3.2 expected goals.
expected
Power play
Cutter Gauthier on the power play, 2026–27 through Nov. 8: 10 goals on chances worth 3.7 expected goals.
Six more than expected
Each puck is a Gauthier goal this season. Grey pucks are the goals an average shooter gets from the same chances; black ones are extra.
The numbers

Through Nov. 8. Five-on-five: 4 goals on chances worth 3.2 expected goals, from 59 unblocked shots. Power play: 10 goals on 3.7 expected, from 41. One empty-net goal is excluded.

Yes, but: Beating expected goals is what he does. Teammate Beckett Sennecke called it “the best shot I've ever seen in my life,” and a pro scout on The Athletic's preseason panel named him the best bet to be the NHL's next 60-goal scorer. His finishing was in the top 5% of regular forwards last season. That's a case for the shot, and we agree with it. It isn't a case for one in four.

The bottom line: The shooter was already here; he went nine games without a goal right before this, shooting at the same rate on the power play. What's new is the four minutes a night Anaheim gives him there, and that can last. A unit converting 59% of its chances can't.

Go deeper

Keep reading