Patrik Laine: Same shot, same 5 on 5 problem.
The power-play-only look is one season old. What's changed is that he's played 75 of 246 games in three years.
Patrik Laine is 28, a free agent and still unsigned nearly a week into the 2026–27 season. The case against him came from Carter Hutton on Daily Faceoff LIVE last month: "He's not going to give you great five-on-five minutes. He's got to be kind of on the power play." That describes Laine at almost any point in his career. What's new isn't the player. It's how little of him anyone has seen.
The shot and the problem arrived together
Winnipeg took him second overall in 2016, and he was what the pick promised: 36 goals as a rookie and 44 the next season. The other half of his game arrived with the shot. Over ten seasons, his finishing, scoring more than his chances deserved, ranks in the top 5% of regular forwards. His five-on-five play, the chances he helps create weighed against the ones he gives up, ranks in the bottom 5%.
That pattern is the spine of his career. The shot hasn't been as loud since his first two seasons, but it has ranked in the top 30% every season he played enough to rank, and five-on-five play has given much of it back, or more. Added up over ten seasons, the two have almost exactly cancelled out, about four wins earned and about four given away.
Columbus bet on the shot and got one good five-on-five season
Winnipeg traded him to Columbus in January 2021, with Jack Roslovic, for Pierre-Luc Dubois. In July 2022, the Blue Jackets signed him for four years and $34.8 million, $8.7 million a season. "He is a special player, one of the truly elite goal scorers in the National Hockey League," Jarmo Kekalainen said at the signing. On the shot, he was right.
The first season of that deal is the one that doesn't fit. In 2022–23, his five-on-five play ranked in the top 30%, the one year it helped him rather than cost him.
The next season lasted 18 games. He broke his clavicle in December 2023 and entered the NHL/NHLPA player assistance program the following month. In August 2024, Columbus traded him to Montreal with a 2026 second-round pick for defenceman Jordan Harris.
Only one season leaned on the power play
His Montreal debut waited until December, after he sprained his left knee in a preseason game. Then came the season that fits the label: 20 goals, 15 of them on the power play. That was fourth in the NHL, and no one who played at least 40 games scored more power-play goals per game. He scored three goals at five-on-five in 52 games.
The chart puts that season in its place. Before it, the power play supplied about a third of his goals, and only once did it reach half. A goal mix that tilted that far, for one year, says more about that year than about him.
Those 15 power-play goals were his shot at work. The chances he took on the power play that season were worth 5.4 expected goals, so he scored nearly three times what his looks were worth. Even for him, that was extraordinary: from 2018–19 through 2022–23, he scored 40 power-play goals on chances worth 34. At five-on-five it ran the other way, three goals on chances worth 4.7. His finishing for the season ranked in the top 5%. One season ran hot in one situation and cold in the other, and the gap made him look like a different player.
What changed is the ice time
The real change is how much he's played. His even-strength ice time fell from 15.8 minutes a game in 2022–23 to 11.3 in 2024–25. Minute for minute, his five-on-five play over the last three seasons was about what it had been from 2016–17 through 2022–23; he just played fewer of those minutes, in fewer games: 75 of a possible 246 over those three seasons. That's why the recent bars on the first chart are smaller.
He hasn't played since Oct. 16, 2025. He had core-muscle surgery later that month and was practising again by mid-January, but he stayed on injured reserve. In March, asked whether Laine could be activated, Martin St-Louis answered with one word: "No." Montreal reached the conference final without him.
Both sides spoke in June. "I probably could have played pretty soon after New Year's," Laine said. General manager Kent Hughes: "He was so behind since he didn't play, and we were put in a situation where we absolutely had to win." Laine also said: "I just kind of need an opportunity." A month later, on July 1, his contract ran out.
What a team would be buying
The most generous case for him came from Oilersnation's Sean Panganiban in June: "Laine may not be a stalwart defensively, but if he can be had on an inexpensive contract, it's a low-risk, high-reward type of deal worth exploring." We'd sharpen the first half. The problem isn't only defence: over his career, he's been in the bottom 10% at both halves of five-on-five play, creating chances and preventing them. But the second half holds, because the reward is the one skill that has held up. Panganiban suggested a one-year deal of $1.5 million to $2 million with bonuses.
Two things would change our view. A full season of five-on-five play anywhere near 2022–23 would make a bonus deal look cheap. A shot that stopped beating its chances would leave nothing to pay for. Whoever signs him is getting a shot worth paying for and five-on-five minutes that need protecting. We'd take the one-year bonus deal. The risk is the calendar, not the player.
Go deeper
Players and teams