Skip to content

Toronto paid for Marchenko's best. Now it needs it back.

His points barely moved last season, but his overall contribution fell by more than half. The Leafs have committed star money to a winger whose best season still stands alone.

3 min read

Toronto has bought the exciting version of Kirill Marchenko: the winger who can carry the attack, threaten with his shot and make a defence worry about the pass too. The problem is how often that version has shown up.

The Leafs acquired him in a deal that sent Matthew Knies to Columbus and signed him for $12.5 million a season. His six-year, $75 million extension begins in 2027–28. That's a commitment to a core player, and Toronto's general manager has said as much.

“While it’s an expensive player, we think it’s a player that fits and we can build around,” John Chayka told Sportsnet.

There is a season in Marchenko's record that makes that ambition look entirely reasonable. There just isn't a second one yet.

The appeal goes beyond his goals

Marchenko's offence is substantial. Across 2023–24 through 2025–26, with each contribution measured per 82 covered games, his five-on-five chance creation ranked in the top 20% of regular forwards. He also scored more than his chances were worth, with finishing in the top 15%.

That helps explain the attraction better than last season's 27 goals alone. Coach Jim Hiller has highlighted his speed with the puck and his ability to threaten as both a shooter and a passer. Toronto has added someone who can help make the chances, then finish them.

The cost deserves the same clarity. Knies wasn't spare change: he had 66 points last season and five years remaining at $7.75 million a season. That was one point fewer than Marchenko, though his own five-on-five game had fallen sharply. Those similar point totals don't settle which player is better. They do mean Marchenko's scoring line alone cannot explain why this was worth doing.

Over the full three-season window, Marchenko's wins above replacement per 82 games placed him in the top 20%. That's a very good forward. Toronto's commitment asks for something more sustained than the peaks and dips underneath that average.

The missing piece isn't just defence

Measured season by season, Marchenko's 2024–25 was a top-5% performance. His chance creation was among the league's best, and his prevention was slightly above average. He drove the attack without handing much back.

Last season, both halves moved the wrong way.

Marchenko's five-on-five chance creation and prevention in wins above average per 82 games, from 2023–24 through 2025–26. Creation peaked in 2024–25; last season it fell while prevention turned sharply negative.

His creation remained strong, but the damage at the other end erased almost nine-tenths of that advantage. His net effect on five-on-five chances ended up around average. The goals and assists still arrived; his edge in chances largely disappeared.

It's tempting to make this a simple assignment for Toronto: keep the offence, fix the defence. But his decline in creation was just as large as his decline in prevention. Getting back to his best requires more from him with the puck as well as without it.

That's why the scoresheet understates the change. Marchenko went from 74 points in 79 games to 67 in 76. His WAR per 82 games fell by more than half. Better power-play work helped last season, but couldn't replace what he'd lost at five-on-five.

Chayka's case has real evidence behind it: Marchenko has already played like a star. Another season pairing exceptional creation with respectable prevention would give Toronto's commitment much firmer ground. Improving his defence while producing another similar points total would still leave the question of his chance creation open.

The Leafs paid to build around Marchenko. The standard now is to drive games the way he did at his best, often enough that 2024–25 stops looking like the exception.

Go deeper

Keep reading