Skip to content

The Leafs lose the NHL's stingiest defenceman — again

The Leafs put Chris Tanev on injured reserve Monday, two days after he lasted just five shifts in a win at Colorado, and he's the defenceman they can least afford to lose.

1 min read

Why it matters: Toronto has been here before. A concussion, a stretcher exit and core-muscle surgery held him to 11 games last season. TSN's Mark Masters calls his absence a big reason the Leafs finished 31st in goals against.

He turns 37 in December, and coach Jim Hiller reportedly isn't sure how long he'll be out (theScore, citing Sportsnet).

  • It's no one-year blip. He was in the top 5% of regular defencemen at keeping five-on-five chances down in each of his last two full seasons, first with Calgary and Dallas, then with Toronto.
  • It's most of his game. He gives a little back on offence, but his defence carries him into the top 10% by WAR per 82 games.
  • The next-best Leaf is a long way back. Nick Blankenburg, who made his season debut the night Tanev got hurt, is a distant second at keeping chances down.
  • The penalty kill loses a workhorse, not its best killer. Tanev plays more penalty-kill minutes per game than about 85% of regular defencemen, but Jake McCabe plays just as many and has been the better penalty killer.
Tanev leads regular NHL defencemen in chance prevention per 82 games, ahead of Adam Pelech.

How he plays: "I don't know if I've ever seen a D-man block as many shots as he does," Craig Berube, then his coach, said in December 2024.

The bottom line: Toronto can find someone to play Tanev's minutes. It doesn't have anyone who defends like him.

Go deeper

Keep reading