Skip to content

Knies scored 66 points and ranked dead last at five-on-five

His WAR fell by about two wins last season, and nearly all of it went at five-on-five.

1 min read

Matthew Knies, traded to Columbus today for Kirill Marchenko, scored 66 points in 2025–26 while his five-on-five game fell apart.

Why it matters: Columbus gave up Marchenko and takes on $7.75 million a year through 2030–31. His point totals keep rising; his five-on-five play last season says otherwise.

  • From good to worst. He went from the top quarter of regular forwards at five-on-five to last of 377. No forward who played regular minutes in both seasons fell further.
  • Both ends went at once. His chance creation and prevention each fell by about a win.
  • Fewer goals, mostly from fewer chances. Leaving out empty-netters, his goals fell from 28 to 18, and his chances were worth about six and a half fewer goals: he shot less often and a little less dangerously, though still 23rd per attempt among regular forwards. His finishing slipped too, from above average to a bit below.
Change in Knies's WAR from 2024–25 to 2025–26: about a win lost at each end at five-on-five, a little on finishing, small gains elsewhere.

Yes, but: The Leafs Nation's Arun Srinivasan calls him "an ascending power forward who fought through a lingering knee injury." Knies himself said the injury was less serious than reported and that he missed only about three games. The limit: his plus-minus cratered after November, plus-2 before and minus-32 after, but so did Toronto's goal differential, and those numbers can't say how much of it was the knee.

The bottom line: The biggest change wasn't his scoring. It was the chances Toronto created and gave up with him on the ice at five-on-five. Columbus is paying for the 2024–25 player, and 66 points can't tell you whether that's who it got.

Go deeper

Keep reading